Are Brokerage Buyers Discounting Themselves Out of Great Opportunities?
Some buyers are so focused on avoiding a bad acquisition that they’re passing up a great one. They’re making offers substantially below supported fair market value because they may be discounting the same market conditions twice: once in the valuation and again in their offer. And they may not even realize they’re doing it.
Over the past year, I’ve seen this happen often enough that it deserves attention. A brokerage owner finally decides to sell after years, sometimes decades, of building a business. The owner understands that transaction counts and earnings are down, and that today’s transaction may require payments over several years.
We complete a comprehensive valuation, considering earnings, market position, agent retention, operating expenses and risk. Then come weeks of discussions and financial reviews. Finally, an offer arrives that is so far below the supported valuation that the conversation effectively ends.
The buyer’s explanation is familiar: transaction counts are weak, mortgage rates are uncertain, and nobody knows when the market will recover. These concerns are legitimate. But uncertainty alone is not evidence that a brokerage’s performance will deteriorate further, particularly when its recent results tell a different story.
Buyers should scrutinize acquisitions more closely in a difficult market, not less. They should also distinguish risks already reflected in value from new risks uncovered through due diligence. In a weak market, buyers need to be more analytical, not more pessimistic.
Here are five areas every brokerage buyer should examine before passing on an acquisition.
